WIMN’s Voices: A Group Blog on Women, Media, AND…

Facing Race: Beyond the Supreme Court

GuestBloggers Icon Posted by Guest Blogger

July 3rd, 2007

By Guest Blogger Tammy Johnson

Last Thursday’s Supreme Court decision on school desegregation efforts headlined every major paper, newscast and blog across the country. Even if you only gave passing notice to the news, you got their message. The highest court of the land is divided on the issue of race, and as a result we now have to tiptoe around the problem of desegregation schools. But that was only half the story. The real story is embedded in the reality of naming race as an issue.

Last week the media, as it usually does, threw out a lot of important words and concepts with limited definitions and context. Words like “diversity,” “race-consciousness,” “discrimination,” and “colorblindness” were all key to describing the impact of this decision. What was not said was even more important, as each word is loaded with historic, legal and social baggage that Americans have carried for decades, if not centuries.

“The way to stop discrimination on the basis of race is to stop discriminating on the basis of race,” said Chief Justice Roberts, speaking for Justices Antonin Scalia, Clarence Thomas and Samuel Alito. Discrimination is a term that is loosely thrown about by many without really understanding its more discerning legal standard. Legally proving discrimination, of any type, means jumping an ever-rising bar of proving intent. During this same session the Robert’s Court ruled in Ledbetter v. Goodyear that a woman now has just 180 days to prove that her employer intended to discriminate against her. Although Goodyear dealt with gender discrimination and the Seattle and Louisville cases with race and schools, both raised the bar proof and remedy to absurd heights. This makes Justice Roberts’ matter-of-fact tone around racial discrimination ironic at best, and disastrous at worst.

Washington University Constitutional Law Professor Samuel Bagenstos puts it best when he says, “Chief Justice Roberts is making an awfully doubtful empirical assertion here, without providing any empirical evidence. And the normative premise that school districts must take private discrimination as they find it, with their hands tied from responding to it, seems to me totally unjustifiable.”

Then there is the question of diversity. In her 2007 film A Girl Like Me, 17-year-old Kiri Davis reprises psychologist Kenneth Clark’s doll experiment, where Black children repeatedly choose the “prettier” white dolls to one of their own race. Because it so starkly illustrated the psychological impact of segregation, the study provided a sociological underpinning for the Brown ruling. But post-Brown we have learned a hard lesson. There can be diversity without equity. We know from countless studies that even fully and partially integrated schools experience racial “achievement gaps” and other disparities across race. Diversity as a solution primarily addresses the symptoms of racism––with the goal of minimizing racial tensions and maximizing people’s ability to get along. That’s a good and worthy goal, but not good enough. If we want to ensure equity, and that all children get what they need, then that requires strategies and solutions that consciously deal with race. Who has access to high quality teachers, curriculum, funding and all the particulars needed for schools that are conducive to learning, are difficult questions that must be asked and answered.

And this leads us to the ever-growing insistence on adopting a so-called colorblind approach to our nation’s racial problems, a notion regularly espoused by conservative commentators. This doctrine posits that if you negate race as an issue, then there will be no racism or racial discrimination. It assumes that racism is just a remnant of past wrongs. It’s an individual act of a few bad apples. It’s something that we had better just get over. But here again, fact trumps fiction. Again, countless studies and investigations have exposed that institutional racism is alive and thriving in almost every industry and governmental service you can name, from the redlining of whole communities by insurance agencies, to the tracking of students of color as district policy. The reality –- often ignored by corporate media but exposed regularly in independent magazines such as ColorLines — is that, intentional or not, institutions through their policies, practices and power oftentimes advantage and disadvantage whole groups of people along racial lines.

A good example of this was a major class-size reduction initiative that was implemented in California’s public schools in the early 1990s. The new law provided state money to any school that was ready to reduce its classes in the primary grades. But schools that predominately served students of color didn’t have the additional classroom space needed in order to take advantage of the policy. The unintended effect was to create a mass flight of qualified teachers from urban poor schools to white suburban schools, leaving schools that serve mainly students of color with a glut of emergency-permitted, underqualified teachers. Now, students of color in the high-need schools are now even worse off because issues of racial equity were never sufficiently addressed in an explicit way when developing this new policy.

This is why our final word of the day, “race-consciousness,” is so very important. Only by confronting the issue head on, will we be able to begin to address the centuries of harm done by and to our nation. Being race-conscious is not about assigning blame. It’s about crafting solutions that fit the need: racial equity. It’s about putting the components in place that allows everyone to meet their full potential through a path of their own choosing, instead of a de facto course assigned by history. That is racial justice. A first step toward real justice would be cleaning up the public debate around race and public policy. That requires more probing media investigations that take race seriously, and are willing to tell the stories of communities of color that demand solutions that address the causes and the impact of racism in our society.

Guest blogger Tammy Johnson , the Director of the Race and Public Policy Program (RAPP) of the Applied Research Center (ARC), has many years experience as a community organizer, trainer and writer versed in race and public policy.

17 Responses to “Facing Race: Beyond the Supreme Court”

  1. Gabriel Bilchak
    September 18th, 2015 15:15

    hi!,I like your writing very much! proportion we keep in touch more about your article on AOL? I need an expert in this house to solve my problem. May be that’s you! Taking a look ahead to peer you.

  2. adam regiaba
    September 20th, 2015 23:44

    I want reading via and I conceive this web site got some truly utilitarian stuff on it! .

  3. %26%231588%3B%26%231585%3B%26%231603%3B%26%231577%3B%26%2332%3B%26%231603%3B%26%231588%3B%26%231601%3B%26%2332%3B%26%231578%3B%26%231587%3B%26%231585%3B%26%231576%3B%26%231575%3B%26%231578%3B%26%2332%3B%26%231605%3B%26%231610%3B%26%231575%3B%26%231607%3B
    October 1st, 2015 23:29

    Hi. Cool write-up. There’s a dilemma with the internet site in chrome, and you may want to check this… The browser could be the marketplace chief and a big component of other folks will miss your excellent writing due to this issue. I like your Post and I am recommend it for a Web site Award.

  4. spouwmuurisolatie wol
    October 9th, 2015 01:07

    Eventually, the author make an update for a weblog. I used to be waiting anxiously for your own next update. I am hoping you are going to consider updating often so your readers might follow along. I do not have a lot joy in life today but your blog is one of them. I recognize life is busy but I genuinely hope you are going to take the time to maintain us modified on any progress.

  5. Dr Nights PornTube
    October 11th, 2015 18:26

    Thank you for your amazing post! It has long been quite insightful. I hope that you will continue sharing your wisdom with us.

  6. vibrators
    October 13th, 2015 09:16

    Please keep on posting such quality storys as this is a rare thing to uncover these days. I am always searching online for posts that can help me. watching forward to yet another fantastic website. Good luck to the author! all the greatest!

  7. Cheap dedicated server
    November 4th, 2015 23:11

    I gotta favorite this internet site it seems extremely beneficial .

  8. evden is imkanlari
    November 16th, 2015 22:42

    I enjoy this site, will surely arrive back. Make positive you carry on writing high quality posts.

  9. komposithegn
    December 29th, 2015 05:08

    I am curious to locate out what blog system you’re utilizing? I’m experiencing some minor security problems with my latest weblog and I would prefer to obtain anything more risk-free. Do you have got any recommendations?

  10. Neuropathy
    January 3rd, 2016 05:16

    I’m curious to locate out what weblog system you’re utilizing? I’m experiencing some minor security problems with my latest blog and I would prefer to locate some thing more risk-free. Do you might have any recommendations?

  11. firmenadressen kaufen
    January 14th, 2016 07:56

    Your talent is really appreciated!! Thank you. You saved me lots of frustration. I switched from Joomla to Drupal towards the WordPress platform and Ive fully embraced WordPress. Its so considerably easier and easier to tweak. Anyway, thanks again. Awesome domain!

  12. cowhide rug
    January 16th, 2016 23:20


  13. %26%231588%3B%26%231585%3B%26%231603%3B%26%231577%3B%26%2332%3B%26%231603%3B%26%231588%3B%26%231601%3B%26%2332%3B%26%231578%3B%26%231587%3B%26%231585%3B%26%231576%3B%26%231575%3B%26%231578%3B%26%2332%3B%26%231575%3B%26%231604%3B%26%231605%3B%26%231610%3B%
    January 19th, 2016 09:43

    Hello. excellent job. I did not anticipate this. This really is a splendid articles. Thanks!

  14. SpOG Penyedia Layanan Aborsi Menggugurkan Kandungan dengan Proses Aborsi menggunakan metode Vakum Aspirasi
    January 30th, 2016 15:54

    It really is very best to participate in a contest for the most effective blogs on the internet. I’ll advocate this internet site!

  15. diabetes complications
    February 3rd, 2016 01:11

    You are in reality a excellent webmaster. The website loading pace is incredible. It seems that you’re doing any distinctive trick.

  16. Cecil Sirolli
    March 26th, 2016 08:37

    Utterly written subject matter, thank you for information. “No human thing is of serious importance.” by Plato.

  17. http://proteintabletter.top
    June 4th, 2016 09:02

    Thank you so much for providing individuals with an extraordinarily spectacular chance to read critical reviews from this website. It’s usually so beneficial and also full of a great time for me and my office friends to visit your blog more than three times a week to read through the new things you have got. Not to mention, I am also always impressed with all the breathtaking techniques you serve. Certain 3 areas on this page are undoubtedly the finest we have ever had.

Leave a Reply